Best Answer - Chosen by Voters
I highly, highly recommend Felidae, Chicken Soup for the Cat Lovers Soul, or Innova. All these have multiple meats as the first ingredients, and are about as high-quality as you can get without feeding raw.
If you feel those are too expensive, Nutro is a decent brand and doesn't cost too much (about $0.50/can). It's also sold at just about every pet store. Natural Balance and Wellness are also decent wet food brands.
At the very bottom of my recommendations is the Meow Mix Market Selects.. there's no by-products in them at all, and they're pretty cheap. But obviously, they're not top-of-the-line either.
Basically, avoid anything with by-products, and with the exception of the Meow Mix Market Selects, anything that can be found in a grocery or superstore.
Good for you for feeding wet as well! It's so much healthier and better for cats than dry.
Source(s):
Years of experience with cats; numerous book reading; years of being involved in cat forums.